find the latest legal job
Corporate/Commercial Lawyers (2-5 years PAE)
Category: Corporate and Commercial Law | Location: Adelaide SA 5000
· Specialist commercial law firm · Long-term career progression
View details
Graduate Lawyer / Up to 1.5 yr PAE Lawyer
Category: Personal Injury Law | Location: Brisbane CBD & Inner Suburbs Brisbane QLD
· Mentoring Opportunity in Regional QLD · Personal Injury Law
View details
Corporate and Commercial Partner
Category: Corporate and Commercial Law | Location: Adelaide SA 5000
· Full time · Join a leading Adelaide commercial law firm
View details
In-house Legal Counsel & Commercial Lawyers
Category: Corporate and Commercial Law | Location: All Sydney NSW
· Providing lawyers with flexibility and control over when they work, how they work and who they work for.
View details
In-house Legal Counsel & Commercial Lawyers
Category: Corporate and Commercial Law | Location: All Melbourne VIC
· Providing lawyers with flexibility and control over when they work, how they work and who they work for.
View details
ASIC weighs up options after third trial defeat

ASIC weighs up options after third trial defeat

After three trial defeats in a month, the corporate regulator was left pondering late last year as to whether it would appeal the Federal Court decision to throw out its claim again Fortescue Metals Group.

AFTER three trial defeats in a month, the corporate regulator was left pondering late last year as to whether it would appeal the Federal Court decision to throw its claim again Fortescue Metals Group.


Its consideration comes in the wake of a stern warning from the court that allegations of dishonesty against company directors should only be made where there is a reasonable evidentiary basis for them. 


The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has lost its case claiming that Fortescue, and its chief executive Andrew Forrest, had misled shareholders by claiming in 2004 that "framework agreements" with Chinese buyers were binding. 


Justice John Gilmour awarded costs to Forrest and the company after throwing out the civil proceeding. It is anticipated that those costs will exceed $10 million. 


This is the third blow for ASIC in recent months, after NSW and Victorian courts respectively threw out high-profile claims against One.Tel founder Jodee Rich and former AWB boss Andrew Lindberg. 


While ASIC has said it intends to appeal the two earlier decisions, it is yet to signal what it will do about the latest defeat. 


In the long-awaited decision, which took seven months to be handed down, Justice Gilmour said in a 299-page judgment that ASIC's allegation that Forrest had no legal basis to make the 2004 claim about the agreements "surprising". 


"It is difficult to discern why ASIC ran a case alleging that [Fortescue's] board could not have made the disclosures it did if it had obtained competent legal advice," he said. 


"In fact FMG did have the benefit of competent professional legal oversight and advice in relation to its agreements, including the framework agreements," Justice Gilmour said. 


Had ASIC been successful in its claim against Fortescue, Forrest would have been banned as a director of the company in which he holds a $4.3 billion stake. 


The maximum penalties that FMG and Forrest could be ordered to pay, had ASIC been successful, was $6 million and $4.4 million respectively.


But as ASIC considers whether it will move ahead with an appeal, it may consider the warning from Justice Gilmour regarding its own conduct. The judge said that allegations of dishonesty against company directors are "self evidently" serious and are likely to attract the attention of the media. 


"That they are made by the corporate regulator may injure the business of the particular company and will tend to adversely affect the reputations of those against whom the allegations are made," he said. 


"It is important that allegations of dishonesty should be made only where there is a reasonably evidentiary basis for them," Justice Gilmour said. 


He said that unless the allegations are withdrawn, the people accused have to wait until trial before they can be assessed. The directors, meanwhile, "have to live and work in their shadow". In the case of Fortescue, the court proceedings have been running for more than three years. 


Meanwhile, as ASIC considers where to go from here, the court will resume to hear submissions on the handling of costs for the case, which involved about 20 lawyers, including several QCs. 


Forrest himself had engaged the services of Allan Myers QC, Australia's wealthiest lawyer. Fortescue, meanwhile, used John Karkar QC, while ASIC used Neil Evans QC.  







Like this story? Read more:

QLS condemns actions of disgraced lawyer as ‘stain on the profession’

NSW proposes big justice reforms to target risk of reoffending

The legal budget breakdown 2017

ASIC weighs up options after third trial defeat
lawyersweekly logo
Promoted content
Recommended by Spike Native Network
more from lawyers weekly
Dec 14 2017
International arbitration and business culture
Promoted by Maxwell Chambers. This article discusses the impact of international arbitration on t...
Papua New Guinea flag
Dec 14 2017
World-first mining case launched in PNG
Citizens of Papua New Guinea have launched landmark legal proceedings against the country’s govern...
Dec 14 2017
Punishing offenders twice pointless, politicians warned
The president of the Law Society of NSW has warned legislators from other states about adopting cont...
APPOINTMENTS
Allens managing partner Richard Spurio, image courtesy Allens' website
Jun 21 2017
Promo season at Allens
A group of lawyers at Allens have received promotions across its PNG and Australian offices. ...
May 11 2017
Partner exits for in-house role
A Victorian lawyer has left the partnership of a national firm to start a new gig with state governm...
Esteban Gomez
May 11 2017
National firm recruits ‘major asset’
A national law firm has announced it has appointed a new corporate partner who brings over 15 years'...
opinion
Nicole Rich
May 16 2017
Access to justice for young transgender Australians
Reform is looming for the process that young transgender Australians and their families must current...
Geoff Roberson
May 11 2017
The lighter side of the law: when law and comedy collide
On the face of it, there doesn’t seem to be much that is amusing about the law, writes Geoff Rober...
Help
May 10 2017
Advocate’s immunity – without fear or without favour but not both
On 29 March 2017, the High Court handed down its decision in David Kendirjian v Eugene Lepore & ...