ABA joins legal condemnation of PM
The Australian Bar Association (ABA) has criticised prime minister Tony Abbott for his attack on Gillian Triggs.
To continue reading the rest of this article, please log in.
Create free account to get unlimited news articles and more!
ABA president Mark Livesey QC said criticisms of independent courts, tribunals and commissions undermine the rule of law in Australia.
"Real care must be taken to maintain respect for the institutions charged with the responsibility of applying the law and deciding cases,"said Livesey, who noted that this worrying trend was not recent. "The previous government's criticism of the High Court over its immigration decision a few years ago is another example.
"This must stop. Politicians must guard against criticising decision-making simply because they don’t like the decision, and personal attacks on judges or commissioners is never appropriate."
Abbott’s (pictured) recent comments that Human Rights Commission president Gillian Triggs demonstrated “extremely questionable judgement” have drawn the ire of the legal community.
Abbott’s comments were in relation to Trigg’s determination that convicted refugee John Basikbasik’s human rights had been violated under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights by being held in detention for almost seven years after completing his prison sentence.
Triggs recommended that Basikbasik be paid $350,000 in compensation.
“The Human Rights Commission does have an important role to play, but decisions like this do tend to shake people's confidence,” said Abbott.
The ABA said a court or commission does not “decide how odious or worthy a person is”.
“The proper role of any court, tribunal or commission is to apply the law objectively and impartially,” said Livesey.
The Human Rights Law Centre and former Australian Lawyers Alliance president Greg Barns have also questioned Abbott’s comments.
Barns has linked the PM’s attack to the imminent release of children in immigration detention.
“I would be stunned if Dr Triggs’ report was anything other than, not just embarrassing, but shattering to a country which purports to uphold the rule of law, fairness and says it’s about subscribing to human rights protocols,” he told Lawyers Weekly.