As we embrace these advancements, it is crucial to navigate the ethical implications that accompany them. It is essential to strike a balance between leveraging AI for improved productivity as well as ensuring responsible use. By prioritising ethical considerations, we can foster an environment where AI not only drives innovation, but also respects privacy, promotes fairness, and uplifts society as a whole.

The ‘new’ AI technology, Generative AI (“GenAI”) has become a focal point for discussion across nearly every industry, including the legal profession. The potential of GenAI to transform legal workflows is actively being explored and debated, and progressively realised. The underlying technology is complex, however the insights into its functionalities are becoming increasingly clear. The ability to rapidly review, analyse, and report on key findings is a game changer.

What are the ethical implications of using GenAI in legal practice and how can we embrace these technologies to enhance the legal practice, better serve clients, and help shape the future of law?

Ethical implications of using GenAI in legal practice

The integration of GenAI into legal practice presents both exciting opportunities and significant ethical implications that must be carefully addressed. To ensure that GenAI enhances rather than undermines the integrity of the profession, it is essential for the legal industry to develop clear policies regarding its use. This includes informing clients about how AI tools function, the associated risks, and ensuring compliance with stringent security and confidentiality protocols in collaboration with IT and cybersecurity experts.

Lawyers must possess a solid understanding of AI tools to use them effectively and responsibly. While they need not be experts, familiarity with the capabilities and limitations of GenAI is crucial. Ongoing education through self-study, expert consultation, and collaboration with specialised vendors will help lawyers navigate biases in training data and mitigate the risks of inaccurate outputs. Independent verification of AI-generated information is essential to avoid malpractice and ensure fair treatment for all clients.

Ethical implications also extend to billing practices. While lawyers cannot charge clients for time spent learning to use GenAI tools, questions arise about the appropriate billing for refining prompts or improving efficiency. Striking a balance between leveraging AI for efficiency and ensuring fair client charges is necessary. As law firms utilise GenAI, they must consider how efficiencies translate into reduced fees while still delivering value to clients.

Equally for consideration are issues around copyright and ownership of AI-generated content, protection around AI-facilitated scams, awareness of the risks of opinion manipulation through disinformation, and the environmental impact of GenAI due to high energy and water consumption.

As lawyers in the legal profession, we should be relying upon our ultimate duty to the court when using generative AI. A good guide is the Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules in its approach to a lawyer's use of generative AI.

As described by the NSW Law Society, Rule 19 of NSWs implementation of the Uniform Law indicates “Solicitors must ensure they do not mislead or deceive the Court, even if inadvertently. The validity of any material presented to the Court needs to be tested by solicitors, whether or not that material has been produced by generative AI.”¹

Embracing GenAI in legal practice

Embracing GenAI in the legal landscape offers numerous advantages that can transform how law firms operate. By automating the drafting of contracts, briefs, and other documents, GenAI saves time and reduces human error, allowing legal professionals to focus on more complex, strategic tasks. Additionally, AI tools can analyse historical case data to provide insights into potential outcomes, enabling lawyers to develop informed strategies. This efficiency not only streamlines repetitive tasks but also enhances overall accuracy in legal work.

These positive impacts extend to client service as well. AI-powered chatbots improve communication by providing immediate responses to client inquiries, enhancing accessibility and fostering stronger client relationships. GenAI can also facilitate tailored training programs, ensuring legal professionals stay updated on the latest developments and ethical standards in technology.

By leveraging data-driven insights, GenAI empowers lawyers to identify trends and make informed decisions, enhancing the quality of legal services. Its scalability allows firms to adapt seamlessly to varying workloads, whether handling an influx of cases or managing complex legal matters. Ultimately, integrating GenAI fosters innovation, helping firms maintain a competitive edge in a rapidly evolving legal environment while making legal services more accessible and efficient for clients.

The role of GenAI in shaping the future of law

By creating robust standards and fostering a responsible framework for the ethical use of AI, the legal profession can effectively navigate challenges such as misinformation, bias, and intellectual property rights. These guidelines not only encourage innovation but also ensure that the use of AI applications aligns with ethical principles.

Collaboration between legal professionals and technology experts is essential for leveraging the full potential of GenAI. Lawyers need to engage with technologists to gain a comprehensive understanding of AI tools, their capabilities, and their limitations. This partnership will help ensure that AI is implemented effectively and ethically, ultimately enhancing the quality of legal services while mitigating potential risks.

Public awareness and education are critical components in the integration of GenAI into legal practice. By informing clients and the general public about the benefits and risks associated with AI, legal practitioners can foster trust and promote informed decision-making. Furthermore, as governments and organisations develop regulations focusing on safety, transparency, and accountability, these efforts will help create a more equitable legal landscape, ensuring that the advancements brought by AI serve the greater good.

Final thoughts

As we navigate these ethical considerations, we are venturing into uncharted territory. This requires a delicate balance between embracing innovation and maintaining the core ethical principles that have long guided the legal profession. Both the technology and our understanding of its implications will continue to evolve. It's essential for legal professionals to engage in ongoing dialogue about these issues to effectively utilise the power of GenAI whilst upholding the highest ethical standards of the profession.

By staying informed, implementing safeguards, and maintaining a critical perspective on GenAI outputs, the legal profession can enhance efficiency and outcomes for their clients, and play a crucial role in shaping an ethical future for law.

To learn more visit: www.sieradata.com/

¹ https://www.lawsociety.com.au/sites/default/files/2024-07/LS4527_MKG_ResponsibleAIGuide_2024-07-10.pdf