find the latest legal job
Corporate and Commercial Partner
Category: Corporate and Commercial Law | Location: Adelaide SA 5000
· Adelaide CBD · Join a leading Adelaide commercial law firm
View details
Freelance Project Finance Lawyers
Category: Other | Location: All Australia
· Vario are looking for freelance lawyers with experience in project finance ideally within the renewable energy sector
View details
Vario Freelance Lawyers
Category: Construction Law | Location: All Australia
· We are looking for lawyers who appreciate the endless possibilities that a freelance career can offer.
View details
Freelance Construction Lawyers
Category: Construction Law | Location: All Melbourne VIC
· We are looking for construction lawyers who appreciate the endless possibilities that a freelance career can offer.
View details
Banking Associate - 1-6PQE - Allen & Overy
Category: Banking and Finance Law | Location: United Kingdom
· Banking Associate - 1-6 PQE - Allen & Overy
View details
Uncertainty continues as class action settled

Uncertainty continues as class action settled

Maurice Blackburn has settled a shareholder class action with agricultural company Nufarm for $46.6 million, up from $43.5 million announced in August, avoiding a potential court ruling on indirect causation and loss calculation.

Jason Geisker (pictured), principal at Maurice Blackburn, told Lawyers Weekly that with so few shareholder class actions making it to final judgment there is no guidance on assessing damages for an alleged breach of  continuous disclosure obligations. He believes this may be one of the reasons Nufarm agreed to pay an extra $3.1 million to facilitate a settlement relatively early on in the proceedings.

“It becomes very risky for the parties to go forward to a trial and final judgment not knowing what the ultimate outcome will be on the law and not knowing which way the judge will go on the approach to loss,” he said.

More than 3000 Nufarm shareholders, including investment banks, super funds and ‘mum and dad’ investors, alleged the company’s profit forecast of between $110 million and $130 million for 2009-10 was misleading or deceptive. Shares dropped from $5.35 per share to $3.25 per share in one week after the company reduced its profit guidance to between $55 million and $65 million.

Geisker believes claimants should be able to rely on indirect causation when arguing that misleading or deceptive conduct resulted in shares being purchased at an inflated price. But Australian law’s position on this issue has not been determined by the courts, he added.

While Geisker claimed uncertainty doesn’t work in any party’s favour, if an Australian court rejects indirect causation then plaintiffs may face the tougher task of proving they relied on the misleading or deceptive information.

Calculating loss

There aren’t rigid rules on loss calculation either. Generally, loss is the difference between the ‘true value’ of the shares at the time of purchase and the actual price paid but, according to Geisker, in some circumstances it is more appropriate for loss to be calculated as the difference between the price paid for the shares and whatever is ‘left in hand’ upon a sale of the shares.

Other loss measures have included: the difference between the price at which the shareholder bought their interest and the market price that would have prevailed but for the contraventions, and the loss of opportunity to achieve a reasonable rate of return on the money used to purchase the interest in the securities.

“The numbers can be vastly different depending on the loss calculation, so it’s prudent for companies to try and resolve the litigation if they can rather than take the risk that they’re wrong about their view of loss and causation and end up paying significantly more,” said Geisker.

If companies heed Geisker's warning, it may be some time before a method of loss calculation is supported by case law.

“If you’re an investor it’s not in your interest to have your money tied up in the courts for a long wait for what might be the same or less return ... [and] even a final judgement would probably not determine the rights of the parties, with appeals likely all the way up to the High Court.”

Even though Nufarm, by settling, avoided an admission of fault, Geisker claimed that class actions still act as a financial deterrent against companies engaging in unlawful conduct.

Two class action claims were commenced against Nufarm – one by Maurice Blackburn in 2010, the other by Slater & Gordon in early 2011. These actions were consolidated in August 2011. They have since been jointly prosecuted by the two law firms, which Geisker described as a “novel process”.

Like this story? Read more:

Book commemorates diamond milestone for WA law society

QLS condemns actions of disgraced lawyer as ‘stain on the profession’

NSW proposes big justice reforms to target risk of reoffending

Uncertainty continues as class action settled
lawyersweekly logo
Promoted content
Recommended by Spike Native Network
more from lawyers weekly
Debate rises over Victorian judiciary attack
Jan 24 2018
Debate rises over Victorian judiciary attack
The Victorian Bar has become the latest to go on record condemning recent political attacks on the V...
Michelle Quigley QC
Jan 24 2018
Vic Barrister who helped stop major heritage redevelopment joins Supreme Court
Michelle Quigley QC, who assisted a coalition to oppose the redevelopment of St Heliers villa estate...
Building, construction
Jan 24 2018
Building for NSW coroner’s complex slated for early 2019
Efforts to relocate the state coroner’s facilities from Glebe to Lidcombe are on track, according ...
Allens managing partner Richard Spurio, image courtesy Allens' website
Jun 21 2017
Promo season at Allens
A group of lawyers at Allens have received promotions across its PNG and Australian offices. ...
May 11 2017
Partner exits for in-house role
A Victorian lawyer has left the partnership of a national firm to start a new gig with state governm...
Esteban Gomez
May 11 2017
National firm recruits ‘major asset’
A national law firm has announced it has appointed a new corporate partner who brings over 15 years'...
Nicole Rich
May 16 2017
Access to justice for young transgender Australians
Reform is looming for the process that young transgender Australians and their families must current...
Geoff Roberson
May 11 2017
The lighter side of the law: when law and comedy collide
On the face of it, there doesn’t seem to be much that is amusing about the law, writes Geoff Rober...
May 10 2017
Advocate’s immunity – without fear or without favour but not both
On 29 March 2017, the High Court handed down its decision in David Kendirjian v Eugene Lepore & ...