Lawyers doubt viability of govt scheme

By Leanne Mezrani|18 May 2015
Andrew Stone

Personal injury lawyers say the federal government’s National Injury Insurance Scheme (NIIS) is underfunded and impractical.

A survey by the Australian Lawyers Alliance (ALA) and InfoTrack has found that two-thirds of personal injury lawyers believe the NIIS has not been allocated an appropriate level of funding, with nearly half saying the system won’t be able to cope with expected demand.

The vast majority of respondents (83 per cent) said the NIIS will not be positive for Australians.

However, 55 per cent were supportive of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).


The federal government is working with states and territories to develop the NIIS as a federated model of separate, state-based, no-fault schemes for people who have sustained a catastrophic injury.

According to the survey, lawyers are concerned that the NIIS’s no-fault basis will remove an individual’s right to sue for appropriate compensation.

Respondents also expressed concern over health and safety issues, with 43 per cent saying there is no incentive for private business to ensure public safety and that there would be a reduction in health and safety precautions.

ALA national president Andrew Stone (pictured) said the development of the NIIS had largely been done in secret and called for the government to release details of its planned reforms.

This is the second time in recent months Mr Stone has publicly challenged the federal government on policy affecting injured Australians.


In April, Mr Stone slammed proposed changes to the Comcare scheme as “an attack on the rights of the nation’s injured workers”.

Public Service Minister Eric Abetz hit back by criticising the ALA for siding with public servants who “rort the system”.

The Comcare reforms include a crackdown on mental injury claims, taxpayer-funded alternative therapies and compensation paid over the “reasonable actions” of department heads.

Lawyers doubt viability of govt scheme
Intro image
lawyersweekly logo



2020’s top 25 attraction firms revealed

Over 300 charges laid following investigation into law firm

Over 300 charges laid following investigation into law firm

Geraldine Johns-Putra

Lawyers, judges perceived more ethically this year than last


Command centre sold for $80m

Recommended by Spike Native Network