find the latest legal job
Freelance Lawyers
Category: Banking and Finance Law | Location: All Perth WA
· Freelance opportunities through Vario from Pinsent Masons
View details
Freelance Lawyers
Category: Other | Location: All Adelaide SA
· • Qualified lawyer with a strong academic background
View details
Freelance Lawyers
Category: Other | Location: All Melbourne VIC
· • Qualified lawyer with a strong academic background
View details
Insurance Lawyer (1 PAE)
Category: Insurance and Superannuation Law | Location: Brisbane CBD & Inner Suburbs Brisbane QLD
· Great Career Opportunity ·
View details
Insurance and Health Lawyer (1-4 PAE)
Category: Insurance and Superannuation Law | Location: Melbourne CBD & Inner Suburbs Melbourne VIC
· New position to support Growth ·
View details
Water buyback challenge begins

Water buyback challenge begins

A constitutional law clash commenced in the High Court today, with agricultural giant ICM taking on five states and the Commonwealth Government over the validity of the bulk water buyback…

A constitutional law clash commenced in the High Court today, with agricultural giant ICM taking on five states and the Commonwealth Government over the validity of the bulk water buyback scheme.

In a statement of claim first lodged in February, ICM says the $135 million scheme to compensate primary producers for reducing their water use is invalid because the states are not required to offer "just terms". The writ claims compensation in the form of ex gratia payments is discretionary and not based on definable criteria of fair value for actual loss.

ICM, owners of the Cowl Cowl Station and the Hillston Citrust properties in the Lower Lachlan Valley, has been joined by farmer Alan Arnold and 107 others who held groundwater extraction entitlements in the Murrumbidgee area but lost their challenge to the scheme in the NSW Court of Appeal last year.'

Former attorney-general Bob Ellicott QC is representing ICM, but today declined to comment on the case.

Director of the Centre for Comparative Constitutional Studies and Melbourne University Associate Dean Cheryl Saunders said the case would once again raise important questions about the contradictory "just terms" obligations placed on the Commonwealth versus the States in the constitution.

"This is a question that's been raised in the past by similar cases and I'm sure it will be raised again, in fact - how come we've got constitutional arrangements that impose a requirement for 'just terms' only on one sphere of government? That, in itself, is weird," she said.

While the Commonwealth is under a constitutional obligation to offer "just terms" in order to acquire property under section 51(31), the states are under no such obligation.

Pursuant to s 5 of the Natural Resources Management (Financial Assistance) Act 1992, the Commonwealth entered a funding agreement with NSW whereby the Commonwealth provided financial assistance for NSW water management projects

Saunders said the case would hinge on the High Court's characterisation of the funding agreement - whether, when the states acquire property in an intergovernmental agreement with the Commonwealth, the "just terms" requirement is activated.

Characterising the Natural Resources Management Act as an act for the acquisition of property will pose a challenge in itself, according to Saunders.

"There are a number of complications about saying that it is an act for the acquisition of property - one is that the states aren't obliged to accept the money under the relevant sections of the constitution. The grants provision of section 96 authorises the Commonwealth to offer money to the states on conditions, but they [the states] are not obliged to accept, which complicates the characterisation of the act.

"There's also another stream of old - very old - judicial decisions dating from shortly after the Second World War dealing with soldier settlement schemes."

Saunders said the outcome of the case was unpredictable, especially given that many of the relevant cases are old law.

"It's very difficult to know what the High Court is going to do with this ...but the cases are old. Since those cases were decided, the High Court has become rather more interested in the substance of legislative schemes," she said.

"I suspect that the court will not be sympathetic to an argument that looks as if this is just a deal to circumvent the constitution - on the other hand, I don't think it is necessarily just such a deal."

Joining the Commonwealth in court on Monday 24 August are NSW, Victoria, Queensland, South Australia and Western Australia.

- Laura MacIntyre

Like this story? Read more:

QLS condemns actions of disgraced lawyer as ‘stain on the profession’

NSW proposes big justice reforms to target risk of reoffending

The legal budget breakdown 2017

Water buyback challenge begins
lawyersweekly logo
Promoted content
Recommended by Spike Native Network
more from lawyers weekly
Please, Continue (Hamlet), Melbourne Festival
Oct 16 2017
Hamlet suffers slings and arrows of top Victorian barristers
Victorian judges and barristers have performed the unique play Please, Continue (Hamlet) at the Melb...
Julian Assange
Oct 13 2017
When justice fails, according to Assange
WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange has dismissed the capacity of judicial systems to deal with complex...
Aussie anti-terrorism laws, detention of 10-year-olds
Oct 13 2017
Treatment of kids under Aussie anti-terrorism laws an over-reach: ABA
The Australian Bar Association has urged the government to reconsider proposed reforms to Australian...
Allens managing partner Richard Spurio, image courtesy Allens' website
Jun 21 2017
Promo season at Allens
A group of lawyers at Allens have received promotions across its PNG and Australian offices. ...
May 11 2017
Partner exits for in-house role
A Victorian lawyer has left the partnership of a national firm to start a new gig with state governm...
Esteban Gomez
May 11 2017
National firm recruits ‘major asset’
A national law firm has announced it has appointed a new corporate partner who brings over 15 years'...
Nicole Rich
May 16 2017
Access to justice for young transgender Australians
Reform is looming for the process that young transgender Australians and their families must current...
Geoff Roberson
May 11 2017
The lighter side of the law: when law and comedy collide
On the face of it, there doesn’t seem to be much that is amusing about the law, writes Geoff Rober...
May 10 2017
Advocate’s immunity – without fear or without favour but not both
On 29 March 2017, the High Court handed down its decision in David Kendirjian v Eugene Lepore & ...