You have 0 free articles left this month.

VCAT allows negligence claim to proceed against law firm

The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal has rejected a law firm’s bid to summarily dismiss a negligence claim brought by a former client.

November 16, 2026 • By Matthew Taylor
Share this article on:
expand image

Australia-based law practice DWF Law Australia (DWF) has failed in its bid to have a former client’s negligence claim largely dismissed by member Justin Toohey of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT), with allegations concerning an unauthorised settlement and failures to pursue legal claims allowed to proceed.

The claim was brought by Francesco Cordoma, who alleged DWF Law Australia mishandled his legal proceedings and did not act on his instructions, which included pursuing compensation over a damaged water pipeline and settling his County Court proceedings without his authority.

 
 

Cordoma alleged that three firms used between 2020 and 2023 in previous incidents failed to properly pursue his counterclaims and claims over the damaged water pipeline.

Two claims were struck out because Cordoma still had time to sue those firms himself, yet a third firm was allowed to proceed because the six-year limitation period may have expired, possibly losing the opportunity to sue.

DWF was the last of the four firms used by Cordoma and is alleged to have failed to take action against previous solicitors, failed to pursue certain claims against two authorities, settled proceedings without his knowledge, and charged excessive legal fees.

Cordoma had constantly changed law firms as he was dissatisfied that they failed to follow instructions.

His property near Robinvale lost its water supply after a contractor allegedly damaged an underground pipeline during excavation work in 2014, resulting in financial losses.

The contractor sued Cordoma in 2019 over an alleged assault, while Cordoma filed a counterclaim alleging that the contractor had assaulted him and damaged the water pipeline.

Cordoma subsequently brought proceedings against DWF, alleging the firm failed to pursue compensation claims against Parks Victoria and Edwards Environmental Services, and had arranged a $25,000 settlement, which was “not in accordance with his instructions.”

DWF argued that it lacked sufficient evidence from Cordoma to properly bring claims against Parks Victoria and Edwards Environmental Services.

Toohey accepted this opinion, yet the “reasonableness” is a matter that needed to be tested at a full hearing, with the emails provided by DWF not enough to prove that Cordoma’s claim should be dismissed.

Further, it was found that Cordoma had provided enough detail regarding his allegations that the three previous law firms had mishandled his claims, highlighting that the allegations against DWF could not be dismissed.

Regarding the allegations of inflated legal costs, DWF had invoiced Cordoma $9,878 in legal fees but had later refunded $6,000 following his complaint, without admitting liability.

Toohey ruled that his remaining dispute over the $1,500 paid would also need to be considered at a full hearing.

The tribunal dismissed claims relating to DWF failing to sue two firms, but enabled the rest of the case to continue as certain issues needed a full hearing.

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Lawyers Weekly a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Lawyers Weekly as a preferred news source.