A law firm whose claims were dismissed by the NSW Supreme Court has been ordered to pay indemnity costs after unreasonably rejecting a $200,000 settlement offer from a law firm principal.
Justice Tim Faulkner of the NSW Supreme Court has ordered DC Legal to pay indemnity costs to the defendants after unreasonably rejecting a $200,000 settlement offer made more than 18 months before judgment.
Proceedings commenced in December 2020, when DC Legal challenged the distribution of $2.38 million in costs recovered from an HIH insurance class action settlement, alleging it was entitled to a greater share of the proceeds.
DC Legal’s claims against Marcel Joukhador and his firm Harrow Legal over the distribution of the HIH-related funds were dismissed by the NSW Supreme Court in July 2026.
DC Legal’s claims included negligence, breach of contract and breach of fiduciary duty, while Joukhador and Harrow Legal later sought indemnity costs, arguing that the firm had unreasonably rejected their settlement offers.
Joukhador and Harrow Legal initiated a cross-summons in 2021 to recoup alleged overpayments made to DC Legal, but abandoned the cross-summons on the first day of the hearing.
During proceedings, which ran from 2020 to 2026, Joukhador made three settlement offers of $100,000, $200,000, and later $300,000; however, DC Legal did not respond to any of the offers.
In July 2026, the court dismissed DC Legal’s claims as it found that a 2014 agreement between the parties had already set out how the money should be divided, and that Joukhador had not breached that agreement.
DC Legal had failed to prove it was entitled to more than the $500,000 it had already received from the $2.38 million recovered from the HIH proceedings.
It was found that the firm had unreasonably rejected a genuine $200,000 settlement offer made by Joukhador and Harrow Legal in January 2025, despite having low prospects of success for the case.
As such, DC Legal was ordered to pay the legal costs on an indemnity basis from that date, meaning it must cover a greater proportion of its legal expenses.
Justice Faulkner rejected DC Legal’s request to use the $126,764 held in court to settle all costs, noting that the parties needed an assessment process to determine how much each owed.
The court dismissed Joukador’s 2021 cross-summons and ordered them to pay DC Legal’s costs of that claim.
However, DC Legal was ordered to pay the legal costs on an ordinary basis up until January 2025 and on indemnity basis after that date.