BigLaw firm Dentons has issued a warning about the growing impact of artificial intelligence on arbitration, offering guidance to in-house legal teams on navigating emerging risks.
Dentons has examined the growing implications of artificial intelligence for arbitration and the importance of proactive risk management by in-house legal teams.
The firm explored how AI use can affect confidentiality, legal privilege, evidence, time and costs, as well as professional regulations.
The report comes as part of Dentons’ AI and arbitration: What businesses need to know series.
Dentons also considered practical steps that organisations can take before a dispute arises, including bolstering internal AI governance, reviewing record-retention policies and evaluating whether current confidentiality and arbitration clauses in contracts mitigate emerging risks that are associated with AI.
Why AI matters to in-house legal teams
Dentons noted several reasons why in-house counsel should care about how AI use can impact an arbitration.
It was noted that in-house legal teams should be mindful of the confidentiality and privilege risks associated with AI use, as providing pleadings, evidence, commercially sensitive information or privileged material to AI systems may expose a business to confidentiality, cyber security, data retention and legal privilege concerns.
Further, it was highlighted that in-house legal teams should also consider the risks associated with witness preparation using AI, as witnesses who upload documents or communications with counsel into AI tools to summarise events or rehearse cross-examination may compromise legal privilege and potentially undermine their credibility during proceedings.
Dentons also recognised that in-house legal teams should consider the risks of AI-generated evidence, as AI-generated reports may become relevant in future disputes and subject to document preservation requirements.
And in-house legal teams should also be cautious that unreliable AI-generated material can increase dispute-related costs and delays, especially where additional time is required to verify its accuracy.
With the emergence of regulatory and professional protections, Dentons warned in-house teams to ensure that an organisation’s use of AI complies with applicable legal requirements.
In-house legal management of AI in agreements and dispute resolution
Dentons also highlighted that in-house legal teams should review existing contractual confidentiality provisions to determine whether they effectively protect sensitive business information from being uploaded into public AI tools.
It was recognised that contractual confidentiality clauses serve as an integral safeguard against the unintentional disclosure of sensitive data via public AI tools, particularly prior to the implementation of dispute-specific AI guidelines.
The firm warned that in-house legal teams should ensure such obligations extend to employees, contractors, officers and directors, and review whether existing clauses address AI use.
In-house legal teams were encouraged to consider whether AI requirements are most adequately addressed when a dispute arises or included in arbitration agreements beforehand, catering for permitted AI use, disclosure requirements and confidentiality protections.