ACT Bar slams territory government over insurance matters

By Jerome Doraisamy|30 October 2018

While the nation is appalled at the misconduct of insurance companies revealed at the royal commission, the Australian Capital Territory government “intends to hand them control over the lives of the injured and maimed”, says ACT’s representative body for barristers.

“Insurance companies have confessed to charging fees inappropriately, churning policies to create commissions and improperly delaying payments but the government wants to sack the judges and magistrates and let the insurance companies judge who gets payment for their injuries and who does not.”

That is the view of ACT Bar, which says the ACT government proposes to stop insurance payments to motor accident victims who are less than five and 10 per cent ‘whole person impaired’ and it is proposing to let the insurance companies decide who of the injured makes the cut.

“Facial disfigurement; the loss of a breast or breasts; the loss of a testicle; walking with a permanent limp and chronic pain might all fail to make the cut-off,” the Association said in a statement.


“Insurance companies will also be able to decide which treatment and care benefits are reasonable and pay only for what they deem to be necessary.”

Vice president of the ACT Bar Association Mr Jack Pappas added: “What kind of system makes the companies which have to pay the injured, the judge of whether and what if any payments should be made?”

“It is even more naïve when the royal commission has shown that insurance companies will put their profitability ahead of policy holders, morality and even the law itself.”

“Is the ACT government the last group in Australia which still believes insurance companies can be trusted?”

The government has not yet set out how if and by whom the insurance companies’ decisions are reviewable, the Association noted. It also has not decided if an insurance company wrongly refuses a claim, whether the claimants get their costs paid if that decision is overturned.


“Members of the public should be very worried that they are having rights which they have had for hundreds of years are being taken away by the ACT government, by stealth and at the behest of insurance companies,” the Association concluded.

“It will be a tough time ahead if you are a motor vehicle accident victim but absolutely cruisy if you are an insurance company,” Mr Pappas said.

ACT Bar slams territory government over insurance matters
Intro image
lawyersweekly logo


Kingsley Liu and Molina Asthana

Cultural diversity cannot be pushed to backburner

Natasha Blycha

Female-led association launched to support diversity in law and tech

Victoria Magistrates Court

Judicial appointments to Victoria’s Magistrates’ Court

James Jordan

‘Greatest logistical challenge’ in distribution of COVID-19 vaccine

Recommended by Spike Native Network