A lawyer who had her salary slashed in half before being dismissed over anxiety-related personal leave has secured an order for outstanding entitlements, with further penalties still to come.
Yates Beaggi Lawyers (YBL) and principal Farshad Amirbeaggi were ordered to pay more than $136,000 to former employee Tamara Rabadi, who was unceremoniously dumped almost immediately after she tried to take personal leave for anxiety in March 2023.
The sum includes about $20,000 in unpaid salary, in addition to annual leave payments and long service leave.
Rabadi informed YBL of the personal leave not long after her salary was cut from $400,000 to $200,000, inclusive of superannuation, due to the firm’s “very significant financial difficulties”.
After she identified “stress and anxiety” as the reason, Amirbeaggi said he was “prepared to overlook / postpone the notices of termination issued to you earlier this year”, would “stand by” them if she could not work, and advised her last day would be 31 March.
Rabadi responded to say she was “never issued with a notice of termination or even any warning”, and that it was “concerning” for Amirbeaggi to be sending her emails “containing lies”.
“If I can’t take sick leave when I am at my absolute worst, including hardly sleeping, hardly eating, crying and vomiting all day, blacking out, then when am I entitled to it? When I am dead?” Rabadi said.
Two minutes later, Rabadi responded: “I’ve just read the first sentence with an allegation of a lie. You are terminated – summarily. Effective today.” No further payments were made to Rabadi.
Judge James Renwick of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCOA) said the initial threat of termination was adverse action because Rabadi had exercised, and proposed to exercise, her workplace right to take personal leave.
“The challenge to the response by calling it a lie and giving detailed reasons why she was seriously unwell, but not unsympathetic to the plight of the firm, was also the exercise of a workplace right, and it led directly to dismissal, which is adverse action,” the judge said.
“The reasons, in context, are clear: it is actually because of the emails containing the complaints and inquiries about workplace rights, including the allegation of the lie, that she is dismissed.”
As for whether it was a lie, Judge Renwick said the prior notice of termination or warning was issued in February 2023 and addressed to a number of people, including Rabadi and another lawyer.
However, Rabadi was advised by practice/general manager Brooke Maniscalco that the email was directed to the other lawyer’s work performance and that Rabadi had “nothing … to worry about”.
“She had good reason to make the statement ‘I have never been issued with a notice of termination or even any warning’, which was the only specified ‘lie’ in the email,” Judge Renwick said.
The matter will return next month to determine quantum of penalties, whether contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) were serious contraventions, and whether other amounts should be paid.
The FCFCOA had to determine the “significant threshold issue” of whether Rabadi was an employed solicitor or, probably since October 2020, a principal of an incorporated legal practice, a partner in YBL, and a unit holder in the YBL 2020 Unit Trust. If the latter, Rabadi would not have been entitled to protections afforded to employees.
In finding Rabadi was an employee of the firm, Judge Renwick relied on payroll records, payslips, disclosures made by YBL to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), salary and relevant tax deductions, disclosures to Legal Super, and Rabadi’s practising certificate.
There were also several emails that demonstrated the parties to the putative proprietorship agreement did not succeed in making a concluded agreement, let alone one that commenced in October. At its highest, they regarded Rabadi as a “partner” in YBL.
This was in addition to correspondence from Amirbeaggi that showed he remained the controlling mind and the agreement had not been reached, including: “Each of my requests for help/contribution to the firm you want to be partner of cannot be met with silence of I can’t help.”
In an email sent in May 2022, Amirbeaggi invited staff to tender their resignation if they were unhappy with their position or salary.
“My firm, my f--king rules,” Amirbeaggi said.
While YBL and Amirbeaggi placed “great store” that the $400,000 salary was not wages but a share of expected profits, it did not follow that the increased remuneration meant a change in employment status, including where there was no change to business or ATO records.
The closest Rabadi’s status came to changing was in April 2021, when she signed certain documents, including an application for her family trust to become a unit holder in the YBL 2020 Trust. In consideration of being registered as a unit holder, Rabadi agreed to be bound by the terms of the unit trust deed.
However, Rabadi said the units were never issued to her, the proposal lapsed, and her status as an employee never changed.
Citation: Rabadi v CAN 640 543 979 ATF The YBL 2020 Trust (No 2) [2026] FedCFamC2G 2244.