You have 0 free articles left this month.

Two sides of the same ball: Smoothing the rough edges of human memory

The Australian Men’s cricket changing room is divided (70/30 by a solid wall), write Sanjay Selvakumaran and James d’Apice.

November 20, 2026 • By Sanjay Selvakumaran and James d’Apice
Share this article on:
expand image

“MISS PRISM: Memory, my dear Cecily, is the diary that we all carry about with us.

“CECILY: Yes, but it usually chronicles the things that have never happened, and couldn’t possibly have happened. I believe that Memory is responsible for nearly all the three-volume novels that Mudie sends us.”

 
 

– Oscar Wilde, The Importance of Being Earnest

The law (and, it seems, literature) has long recognised that even the most honest among us can have contrasting recollections of the same event.

For litigators and the fact-finders they appear before, any attempt to uncover The Truth® can be (if a Harry Potter reference can be forgiven) like trying to catch smoke.

Human memory can be coloured by self-interest and discontent; a phenomenon well known to anyone acting for a family provision applicant, a shareholder in dispute, or a person disappointed with the conduct of their local constabulary.

What happens when two apparently honest witnesses come forward with their own competing narratives? When selecting between the stories of two truth-tellers, which truth-teller’s version of events will reign supreme?

It’s a problem currently plaguing fans of the Australian men’s test team (one entertaining English fans) and one that confronts lawyers on a day-to-day basis. Thankfully, the legal system, unlike the “forum” of public opinion, has developed tools to deal with it.

Usman Khawaja’s book – Sabr – has scratched off scabs to reveal unhealed wounds.

The facts of ‘sanderpapergate’ are largely banal even if they remain opaque. One former player (Usman Khawaja, supported by a number of others) is seen to have asserted that “everybody” knew a plan had been hatched in 2018 for Australian teammates to unlawfully alter the state of the cricket balls the Australian team were using in order to increase their utility; to induce deadly “reverse swing”. One current player (Patrick Cummins, himself supported by a number of others) has denied “everybody” knew. Others, too, have weighed in.

Solemn, unprecedented punishments were handed out following the 2018 events (although if Khawaja’s view expressed in his autobiography is accepted, those punishments had less to do with the events of Cape Town and more to do with the preceding pay dispute between Cricket Australia and the players).

So, what are we to make of these contrasting accounts? How do we reconcile competing versions of events given by apparently honest and forthright witnesses?

At the risk of penning a love letter to The Law, concepts such as admissibility, prejudice, credibility, reliability and Briginshaw – not to mention punishments for contempt and perjury – have equipped lawyers and judges with tools to navigate the murky waters of competing testimony in a manner which, for the most part, society accepts as fair.

The recent NSW Court of Appeal decision of Davey v Want [2026] NSWCA 12 (a coincidentally named case – as some of this dispute indeed hinges on what erstwhile Khawaja and Cummins teammate Davey (Warner) wants!) traversed this issue in relation to conduct that took place over 50 years ago.

Paragraph [65] of that decision includes:

(I)t is well understood that people can honestly “remember” “events,” but that memory does not necessarily mean that the event actually occurred. This is the difference between fabricated evidence and unreliable evidence. Honest evidence as to a memory goes only so far in proof. The next important question is the reliability or accuracy of that evidence. It is at this point that an understanding of the fallibility of human memory has an important part to play.

The law accepts that what we “remember” sheds little light on the “event”.

Even while the averments of Sabr were taking shape, the NSW Court of Appeal was reminding us about the distinction between reliability and credibility in Stanley v NSW [2026] NSWCA 241.

This leaves Khawaja, Cummins, and those of us looking on with rapt attention at something of a standstill: we have neither The Truth®, nor do we have a liar!

What then for the protagonist of this most recent rendition of the sandpaper saga, Usman Khawaja? Is it as simple as “ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat”, meaning “the burden of proof lies on the one who asserts, not on the one who denies”? Probably not, but the gravity of the allegations made by Khawaja, Warner and now their former teammate Cameron Bancroft, among others, certainly warrant, but will not get, the rigour and discipline of a courtroom analysis. In the meantime, the absence of a curial proceeding which delimits the scope of the inquiry by relevance, and mandates that allegations are made with specificity, the entire sorry story remains devoid of detail, which, as we all know, is where the devil domiciles.

Perhaps, just as the courts have had to make peace with competing “truths”, so must we men’s cricket observers learn to walk and chew gum at the same time. If only there were some way to smooth such a rough outcome…

Sanjay Selvakumaran is a partner at Hugo Law Group, sits on the committee of the Australian Lawyers Cricket Council, and has been a fan of Usman Khawaja’s cover drive since seeing it from the non-striker’s end in Sydney’s eastern suburbs decades ago. James d’Apice is a semi-competent cricket scorer and principal lawyer of Gravamen, a firm that sponsors among other things the North Sydney Bears, the Terrigal-Matcham Bellbirds, and some sports podcasts.

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Lawyers Weekly a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Lawyers Weekly as a preferred news source.