The sole principal of a small Melbourne firm was penalised over sexual banter with his law clerk, which the court said was “unlike anything one would expect to encounter in a solicitor’s office”.
At times, Judge Jonathan Forbes appeared at a loss to make sense of the unusual relationship between MP Lanza Lawyers sole principal Mario Peter Lanza and former law clerk Crystal Fonua, which became mired in “bizarre” he-said/she-said allegations.
In her claims under the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) before the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCOA) (Division 2), Fonua painted Lanza as an alleged “pathetic and ageing predator” who exploited his power for sexual gratification.
Lanza, who vehemently denied the allegations, claimed Fonua was a “scheming and manipulative gold digger” who exploited her knowledge of his vulnerabilities as part of a “catfish” sting.
“Critical legal questions, such as whether Lanza’s conduct was subjectively unwelcome or whether a reasonable person would anticipate the possibility that Fonua would have been offended, humiliated or intimidated by his conduct are not easily answered, with every action and reaction of the parties having to be viewed through the tangled web of an unconventional, volatile and at times dysfunctional emotional relationship,” the judge said.
Both parties presented “wildly different narratives”, neither of which Judge Forbes found to be convincing. The evidence – which, at times, was found to be wanting – was so incomplete, self-serving and inconsistent that Judge Forbes said he could not find the truth by preferring one witness’ narrative over the other.
“In the end, the evidence in this case invited far more questions than it delivered answers,” Judge Forbes lamented.
Ultimately, Judge Forbes found Fonua was the victim of sexual harassment to some extent and ordered that Lanza pay her unpaid wages of $1,429.55, plus interest; $12,000 by way of future economic loss (less any WorkCover or JobKeeper payments); and $35,000 in compensation for the hurt, distress, humiliation and distress Fonua suffered as a result.
Given the significantly blurred lines in Lanza and Fonua’s lengthy personal and professional relationship, the sum is substantially less than the $656,832.19 that Fonua was seeking.
Fonua’s claims she was discriminated against based on imputed disability, namely mental health, was dismissed.
Judge Forbes also dismissed a cross-claim brought by Lanza over allegations Fonua had driven and damaged the “prize” of his car collection – a 1975 Porsche 911 Carrera 2.7 MFI – while it was stored in her home garage for approximately 13 months.
Friend? Client? Employee? Lines blur over several years
How Lanza and Fonua came to know each other, and came to be in an employment relationship, was critical in Judge Forbes’ decision-making. However, he noted that much of the evidence on this was just as “vague” and inconsistent as the rest.
The court was told Fonua had been friends with Lanza’s wife, Krsyal, who died tragically in September 2014. The year prior, Fonua approached Lanza for assistance with a legal matter, and Lanza agreed at the encouragement of his wife.
Their relationship prior to Fonua becoming his employee in February 2020 was described as “volatile”, with lengthy periods during which they were not in contact due to some tensions.
Around Christmas 2019, the court heard Fonua repeatedly sought part-time employment with Lanza. He claimed she incessantly called him and showed up at the office to discuss this and the prospect of her undertaking her legal studies at the same time.
Referring to the four-and-a-half-month employment relationship that followed, Judge Forbes said neither party was able to produce a full suite of communications “which might have allowed a reconstruction of something approaching the truth”.
Instead, what Judge Forbes had were portions of one-sided correspondence from texts, photos and screenshots, in which the other party’s responses were incomplete or missing.
However, Judge Forbes was able to determine there was a continuous legal relationship of employer-employee between February and June 2020, albeit “in name only” to some extent.
Many conversations had ‘sex written all over them’
Counsel for Lanza conceded Lanza had an affection for Fonua that may have been misplaced, but claimed it was not sexually motivated, even if many of their discussions had “sex written all over them in terms of the subject matter or in … language”.
Counsel argued that for conduct to be described as being of a sexual nature, it needs to be “charged with some form of motive or intent which would lead to sexual conduct, sexual advance or something along those lines”. Judge Forbes did not agree.
There were 10 instances that were found to be of a sexual nature, including a photo sent to Fonua of Lanza’s naked torso, a message that expressed his love and affection for her, comments of a man “blowing his load”, and a text that suggested the “taxman” was watching “every quiver, every moment of your boobs”.
Lanza conceded his comments were “in poor taste, crass, childish, crude and, save for context, quite possibly offensive and unacceptable in other quarters”. However, he denied Fonua was an unwilling and disengaged victim of his “smutty barrage”.
Judge Forbes found just three incidents were unwelcome, noting that it needed to be assessed at the time of the conduct and determined by having regard to Fonua’s true subjective beliefs.
After much reflection, Judge Forbes said he did not feel “an actual persuasion that Fonua found most of Lanza’s conduct to be subjectively unwelcome at the time”, including because the seeds of some of his sexualised commentary was “introduced to him in some way, shape or form” by Fonua’s own comments.
“Lanza did not make it up and his lewd and explicit conduct did not fall from thin air. Fonua’s contribution to the sexualised discussion weighs against a finding that Lanza’s engagement was subjectively unwelcome,” Judge Forbes said.
Judge Forbes also noted much of the conduct complained of was presented without context, there was no “objective evidence of discouragement” on Fonua’s part, and the “sheer volume of communications … belies any general sense of unwelcomeness”.
“The content of some of Lanza’s texts or messages are frankly depraved and repulsive, despite his belief that he was being funny. He pushed the boundaries. He engaged in acts of fantasy and adopted the persona of people he did not know in some of his exchanges with Fonua,” Judge Forbes said.
“It is difficult to imagine the conduct would be acceptable in any setting, but in the very unusual and somewhat bizarre boundaries of the particular relationship between Lanza and Fonua, I find that for the most part Fonua did not find Lanza’s sexualised conduct to be unwelcome. Pushing the boundaries of acceptable conduct is what Lanza and Fonua did within their cocoon.”
The unwelcome sexual conduct
The first of the three unwelcome incidents concerned a text message, written by Lanza as if it were sent by Fonua, that suggested she was open to a threesome with one bisexual man who would engage in homosexual activity with the other man.
While Judge Forbes said the offence was “short-lived and a case of Lanza over-stepping the mark”, he accepted Fonua would have found the text to be disgusting and offensive to her moral code.
In the second, Fonua was sitting an online examination for her law degree when Lanza held up sexualised images, including a photo of her sister with the words “I suck dick” drawn over her face, and doctored images of Fonua, her husband and his new partner.
“I find it difficult to conceive of any world in which a person, sitting for an important exam, would welcome conduct of the type admitted by Lanza,” Judge Forbes said of this incident.
The third concerned a phone call with Lanza, Fonua and Fonua’s friend, Ms P, who had recorded it without Lanza’s knowledge. It occurred on the day Fonua’s employment came to an end.
Judge Forbes said the written transcript could “never convey the colour and theatre of what transpired”, adding it was a “lengthy, spectacular and bizarre discussion, full of expletives, sex talk, denigration and completely unbecoming of mature adults”.
At one point, Lanza said: “I asked Crystal out on a date. She said she is not ready. Well, then, fine, f--k off. I don’t want to see you anymore. You know what Crystal had said, that's not fair. I said yes, it is. F--k off. Crystal, you’re out of a job. Off you go.”
“It was unprofessional in the extreme, unlike anything one would expect to encounter in a solicitor’s office between a principal lawyer and his legal assistant,” Judge Forbes added.
He said the call “crossed even the widest boundaries of their relationship”. Further, Lanza’s conduct in describing Fonua as “a distraction” in the office and telling her to leave the office because she would not date him was subjectively unwelcome.
Another call later was relevant to Lanza’s thesis he had been set up by Fonua for the alleged “catfish” sting, including her comments about his “$50 million cars” and the garaged Porsche.
Judge Forbes found no basis for Lanza’s catfish theory, and no premeditation in Fonua’s conduct or evidence that she had been playing some long game intended to catch him on a phone call.
“Fonua might have acted opportunistically in bringing this litigation, but it is not the malicious set up Lanza believes it to be.”
Citation: Fonua v Lanza [2026] FedCFamC2G 2276.