Employment lawyers have examined the legal implications of a Fair Work Commission ruling on abandonment of employment, noting the lessons for employers navigating unexplained employee absences.
For employers, handling unexplained employee absences can be complex, posing notable legal and procedural challenges when evaluating potential abandonment of employment.
Such issues were considered in the Fair Work Commission’s decision in Mr Md Abdullah Haque v dnata Airport Services Pty Ltd [2026] FWC 1698, in which the commission found that dnata had dismissed Haque after he stopped attending work and failed to respond to repeated attempts at contact.
The ruling addressed the importance of appropriate communication and processes in the workplace.
Talking to Lawyers Weekly, Holding Redlich partner Stephen Trew and associate Chloe Hamer discussed the legal implications and practical considerations for employers.
Implications of the abandonment ruling
Trew explained that while the decision doesn’t necessarily establish binding precedent, it highlights the importance of how employers communicate their position when dealing with the possibility of abandonment of employment.
“As this ruling is a single member decision, it does not create a binding precedent regarding how abandonment of employment is treated under the Fair Work Act,” Trew said.
“It does mean that the wording of any communications by the employer will be more carefully considered to assess whether they contain language of ‘acceptance’ or language of ‘termination’, with the latter opening the door to the various ‘dismissal’ based jurisdictions.”
Trew further pointed out that the commissioner’s remarks must be viewed through the lens of the jurisdictional hearing.
“The comments made by the commissioner may also reflect the procedural context in which the ruling was made,” Trew said.
“This is because the ruling concerns a jurisdictional hearing, in which the commissioner was required to determine whether the employee had been ‘dismissed’ before the Fair Work Commission could exercise its powers to deal with the dispute by way of conciliation.
“This was a requirement following the Federal Court of Australia decision in Coles Supply Chain Pty Ltd v Milford [2020] 279 FCR 591 (Coles v Milford), which had created an increase in complex jurisdictional hearings in the Fair Work Commission.
“This requirement has now been removed for general protections and unfair dismissal applications made on or after 7 July 2026, following the passage of the Workplace Relations Legislation Amendment (Building Cooperative Workplaces No.1) Act 2026 (Cth).”
Next steps before declaring abandonment
Trew recognised that employers must take reasonable steps to establish whether an employee has legally abandoned their employment before determining whether the employment contract should be terminated.
“Employers should not assume that a prolonged, unexplained absence means an employee has abandoned their employment,” Trew said.
“Before sending any correspondence ending the employment or stating that it has ended, employers must be able to demonstrate that they have taken reasonable steps to enquire into why the employee has been absent and established a position where it is reasonable to conclude that there has been a renunciation of the employment contract.
“This means considering whether the employee’s conduct shows that they are no longer willing or able to perform their obligations under the employment contract.”
In addition, he emphasised that any choice to accept an employee’s repudiation has to be conveyed in writing.
The wording must be carefully formed to separate the acceptance of the worker’s conduct from an action of termination initiated by the employer.
“If an employer decides to accept the repudiation, it would be necessary to communicate this to the employee in writing,” Trew said.
“As demonstrated by the decision, it is important that any such correspondence is carefully worded to avoid suggesting that the employer is proactively terminating the employment on its own initiative, and, rather, that the employer is accepting the employee’s repudiation.”
Legal implications and future decisions on abandonment of employment
Associate Chloe Hamer considered whether the decision could impact how future abandonment cases are handled and what it means for employers managing unexplained absences.
“It is unclear of the extent to which the commissioner’s doubts will lead to changes in how future abandonment cases are decided,” Hamer said.
“The decision remains relevant for employers as it highlights the challenges employers face when dealing with unexplained absences and the importance of corresponding with the employee appropriately and being deliberate in the language used when communicating about the end of the employment.”
Hamer also highlighted the importance of keeping clear records of employee contact attempts and ensuring fairness to help employers manage potential unfair dismissal claims.
“When the Fair Work Commission is considering an unfair dismissal claim it will need to determine whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable,” Hamer said.
“As part of this determination, the Fair Work Commission is required to consider whether there was a valid reason and whether the employee was afforded procedural fairness and an opportunity to respond to any allegation that they have abandoned their employment.
“As such, it is important that employers take simple, but proactive, steps to clearly document each attempt to contact the employee.
“Taking these steps is also important in responding to any potential general protections application as it can be used to demonstrate that the employer did not take adverse action against the employee because of any protected attribute or workplace right.”