You have 0 free articles left this month.

Court vows to ‘expose, determine’ retainer challenge

Concerned with oblique references and one “backdoor challenge” to solicitors’ retainer, the Federal Court has ordered the defendant to clarify whether it will finally be brought into the open.

November 16, 2026 • By Naomi Neilson
Share this article on:
expand image

Justice Michael Lee ordered Suellen Osborne, former managing director and chief executive of Timor Resources Holdings (TRH), to make clear whether she intends to challenge the authority of the solicitors on record to institute Federal Court proceedings.

“The court ought not knowingly case-manage a proceeding for months, directing evidence and taking interlocutory steps, while leaving unresolved a contention that the corporation in whose name the exercise is undertaken never authorised the proceeding.

 
 

“Nor is it fair to the solicitors to leave hanging over them an allegation that they are conducting litigation without authority.

“If the point is maintained, it must be exposed and determined,” Justice Lee said.

The proceedings, described as “hydra-headed” by Justice Lee, relate to a “comprehensive breakdown” in the relationship between those behind THR’s ownership, financing and management.

Once a “comparatively defined dispute”, the proceedings have devolved into “three proceedings, a special jury in the form of a referee, a search order, an outstanding application for asset-preservation relief, competing contentions as to who may speak for TRH, and renewed controversy about investment dealings”.

There are also allegations concerning the retention and use of company property, contraventions of statutory duties, statements said to have been made by Osborne to the petroleum regulator in Timor-Leste, and acts after her executive authority finished.

At the first hearing in August, Osborne’s then-counsel raised the retainer issue, and the following discussion focused on a board resolution the month prior, in which steps were authorised to obtain access to company property and commence litigation.

Although Justice Lee “indicated immediately that the issue required separate and prompt determination”, the challenge was not pursued when proceedings returned in September.

Instead, an objection to the solicitors’ authority was later raised in open court and again identified as a matter “requiring immediate determination and maintained”. When the proceedings returned, it was still not pursued, and the matter advanced “upon the footing that TRH was entitled to obtain its corporate material”.

An oblique reference was then made in mid-October, which Justice Lee said “amounted in substance to a backdoor challenge”. While he again indicated that any such challenge should be raised directly with the court, no such action was taken.

At the time of Justice Lee’s most recent decision, Osborne had included an allegation in her defence that all or part of the proceedings were commenced without TRH’s authority.

On his reading of the pleadings, it concerns authority to commence proceedings, relevant board resolutions and delegations, subsequent ramifications, proceeding amendments, and possible requirement for Special Director Approval.

“Any such issue must now be crystallised,” Justice Lee said.

Citation: Timor Resources Holdings Pty Limited v Osborne (Management of Related Proceedings) [2026] FCA 1705.

Want to see more stories from trusted news sources?
Make Lawyers Weekly a preferred news source on Google.
Click here to add Lawyers Weekly as a preferred news source.