A Melbourne lawyer who called in sick to attend the AFL Gather Round has been ordered to foot his former employer’s legal costs, after unreasonably rejecting several settlement offers.
The Fair Work Commission has ordered lawyer and former Greens candidate Mitchell Fuller to fork over $22,500 to commercial firm Madison Branson Lawyers (MBL), despite his earlier assertions that it was “almost impossible” for a costs order to be made.
Following “heated disciplinary meetings”, Fuller was fired in August 2024 over claims he failed to follow reasonable directions, worked without approval or authority, and missed billable targets.
Several months later, MBL unearthed social media posts that proved Fuller lied about being sick on the Friday and Monday around the AFL Gather Round, held in Adelaide in April 2024.
Noting Fuller’s lies to the firm and to the commission, deputy president Andrew Bell said his conduct and attitude were “utterly incompatible with his ongoing employment as a solicitor”.
Each party ordinarily bears its own costs under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) unless certain conditions are met. In this case, MBL argued Fuller brought the unfair dismissal application vexatiously and without reasonable cause.
Given Fuller was a trained and qualified solicitor, MBL argued he should have known the application had no prospects of success.
Bell noted that MBL made several offers of settlement between October and December 2024, including a $3,000 offer that referenced MBL’s discovery of his Gather Round attendance.
A “walk away” offer was also made on 26 November, in which MBL said Fuller was “disingenuous” by continuing to assert he was owed a payment of sick leave for the Friday before Gather Round.
Fuller rejected each offer.
In one rejection, Fuller said it was “almost impossible” for the commission to make a costs order and denied that his claim was devoid of merit. He also claimed to have “vast” material that allegedly indicated his dismissal was “procedurally unfair”.
The rejection of the $3,000 and walk-away offer was “an unreasonable act”, Bell found. Although the $3,000 appeared modest, Bell said it was “generous” in the context of the dispute.
At the hearing, heard in December 2024, Bell indicated there was likely to be “some significant adverse factual findings” against Fuller and invited him to reflect on this over the lunch break.
During the break, Fuller rejected an offer that he pay MBL $5,000 in exchange for its consent to discontinue the proceedings.
In his costs decision, Bell said it was “difficult to conceive” how Fuller’s unfair dismissal remedy could possibly succeed once the Gather Round facts came to light, “even acknowledging that the assessment by the commission as to whether a dismissal is unfair involves a wide range of discretionary factors”.
“Perhaps most critically, it is difficult to consider how the ongoing employment of Fuller, who was a practising solicitor, was remotely tenable where a significant lack of candour from him towards his employer had been exposed,” Bell said.
In Fuller’s favour, Bell noted the relative lack of clarity in the conduct of MBL’s case prior to their engagement of counsel.
Bell also acknowledged the relative lateness of counsel’s involvement, and aspects of his work that were strictly unnecessary.
The $22,500 costs order represents two-thirds of the actual costs incurred. Fuller had 28 days to pay.
Citation: Mr Mitchell Fuller v Madison Branson Lawyers Pty Ltd [2026] FWC 4148.