Australia’s laws prohibit pregnancy discrimination, yet challenging a redundancy seemingly linked to pregnancy or parental leave can present significant legal and practical obstacles. As the Australian Human Rights Commission calls for reform, employment lawyers are questioning whether existing protections go far enough.
Pregnancy discrimination has been unlawful in Australia for decades. Yet for workers who lose their jobs during pregnancy or parental leave, establishing that an employer acted unlawfully can be a very different proposition from knowing they have legal rights.
Employers can have legitimate reasons to restructure their businesses, including eliminating positions held by employees who are pregnant or on parental leave. The legal difficulty arises when a worker suspects that their pregnancy or absence influenced the decision, but the employer maintains that the redundancy was driven entirely by operational needs.
It is a tension brought into sharper focus by the Australian Human Rights Commission’s (AHRC) October 2026 report, Balancing Act: Supporting Working Parents and Carers, which identifies 18 areas for reform.
Drawing on consultations with 84 stakeholders and a review of existing research, the report highlights a persistent gap between the protections available to pregnant workers and parents and their experiences in the workplace.
For sex discrimination commissioner Dr Anna Cody, the problem extends beyond individual instances of unlawful conduct.
“I think what it reveals about protections for pregnant workers is that they’re just not working,” Cody told Lawyers Weekly.
Despite the prohibition on pregnancy discrimination, she said the burden of pursuing a complaint often falls on workers at an especially vulnerable point in their lives.
“The complaint-based system doesn’t work as a way of protecting women from pregnancy discrimination,” Cody said.
The question for employment lawyers is whether the existing framework is failing to prevent unlawful decisions, making them too difficult to challenge, or both.
When a redundancy raises questions
Under the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) and Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), pregnancy, parental leave and family responsibilities attract a range of legal protections. However, those protections do not prevent employers from making legitimate operational decisions that affect pregnant employees or workers on parental leave.
Speaking to Lawyers Weekly, Holding Redlich partner Megan Cant and special counsel Ashleigh Mills emphasised that the critical distinction lies in the reason for the decision.
“In Australia, it is not unlawful to make an employee’s role redundant during pregnancy or parental leave. It is, however, unlawful to make an employee redundant for either of those reasons,” they said.
“What will distinguish a genuine operational decision from unlawful discrimination or adverse action is the reason for the decision to make the employee’s role redundant.”
Where a redundancy is challenged, evidence of genuine business needs – including financial pressures, technological change, outsourcing or restructuring – can be crucial.
Cant and Mills said employers must be able to demonstrate the legitimate business reasons behind a redundancy, supported by contemporaneous records and evidence from those responsible for the decision.
“The reasons will need to be supported by contemporaneous business records, together with written and oral evidence from the person or people in the organisation who made the decision,” they said.
They added that the timing of the decision, the selection process and communications with the employee are also relevant to assessing whether the decision was genuine.
For Héloïse Williams, a senior lawyer at employment rights organisation JobWatch, however, the difficulty often lies in establishing why one employee’s position was selected.
Williams said workers who suspect discrimination may face different obstacles depending on whether they pursue an unfair dismissal or general protections claim.
“In my experience, when you have this kind of situation, the employer can get over that hurdle, and they can establish that jurisdictional objection,” she said of genuine redundancy arguments in unfair dismissal proceedings.
In those proceedings, an employer may raise a genuine redundancy objection. That requires consideration of whether the job was no longer required to be performed by anyone because of operational changes, together with applicable consultation and redeployment requirements.
A general protections claim instead focuses on whether prohibited reasons, such as pregnancy or exercising a workplace right, influenced the adverse action.
Williams said she has encountered arguments that a role was selected for redundancy not because the employee exercised their right to parental leave, but because the employer discovered during their absence that the position was unnecessary.
“While you were away we realised that we didn’t need your role anymore,” she recalled employers arguing, or that “we could split your duties amongst existing staff”.
Williams questioned how an employer can separate the absence from the employee’s exercise of their right to parental leave, although she acknowledged that the legal inquiry concerns the reasons for the decision rather than simply whether the absence was a factual cause.
She described the arguments that can arise as “linguistic gymnastics”.
Although the Fair Work Act provides for a reverse onus of proof in general protections proceedings, Williams said disputes about the decision-maker’s actual reasons can remain difficult to navigate.
The cost of enforcing a right
For workers who believe their dismissal was unlawful, the practical barriers can arise before a claim is even heard.
Applications involving unfair dismissal or general protections dismissal claims generally must be lodged with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect, subject to limited exceptions.
Williams questions whether that period adequately accommodates workers dealing with pregnancy, childbirth, or the demands of a newborn.
A person who has just lost their employment may also be confronting financial uncertainty, sleep deprivation, and the difficulty of finding legal advice.
“The 21 days off the bat is hard, and it’s difficult,” she said.
The pressure can be particularly acute for people in casual or insecure employment, those with limited financial resources and workers who face language barriers.
“It’s hard enough,” Williams said. “Imagine what it’s like for someone who’s working casually at a bookshop, or someone [for whom] English is their second language.”
The AHRC report identifies similar obstacles. Its account of an earlier national review notes that 91 per cent of mothers who experienced discrimination did not lodge a formal complaint, citing factors including fear, stress and lack of awareness.
The report also describes how concerns about professional reputation, retaliation and the costs of pursuing legal action can discourage workers from seeking remedies.
Williams argues that strengthening statutory protections without improving access to advice and representation risks leaving those barriers substantially intact.
“I agree that the proposed reforms to the SDA and the Fair Work Act, they’d have a big impact. Absolutely, I really do think they would,” she said.
“But of course, as always, the bigger impact would be if they got more resourcing and more funding.”
Williams said additional investment is needed not only for the AHRC but also for community legal and advocacy services, which assist workers who may otherwise struggle to obtain advice or pursue a claim.
The concern is not simply whether a legal remedy exists, but whether a worker can realistically pursue it.
Would shifting the burden make a difference?
Among the Balancing Act report’s proposed reforms is a recommendation to consider placing greater limitations on redundancies affecting employees who have taken, applied for, or are likely to take parental leave.
One suggested approach would require employers to establish that a redundancy is genuine in those circumstances, supported by effective enforcement and meaningful penalties.
Cody said the AHRC heard repeated accounts of employees losing their positions shortly after announcing a pregnancy or while on parental leave.
“We recognise that sometimes businesses will need to downsize,” she said.
However, she suggested placing greater responsibility on employers to demonstrate that a redundancy is genuine, rather than leaving affected workers to challenge the decision after the event.
In her interview with Lawyers Weekly, Cody discussed a possible presumption affecting redundancies within a six-month period around pregnancy disclosure or parental leave.
She explained that the proposal would involve “having the onus on the employer to demonstrate” that the decision was a genuine redundancy.
The report itself does not prescribe that six-month time frame, and the details of any legislative change would require further consideration.
An important legal question is how such a safeguard would interact with existing protections. While general protections proceedings already involve a reverse onus concerning prohibited reasons, an additional measure directed specifically at parental-leave-related redundancies could change how employers are required to justify those decisions.
Cant and Mills cautioned that proposed reforms could increase employers’ litigation exposure, particularly where obligations are broadened or the circumstances in which employees can challenge workplace decisions are expanded.
They also identify uncertainty in the interaction between the Fair Work Act’s return-to-work guarantee and an employer’s ability to make operational decisions during parental leave.
“There is a common misconception that section 84 guarantees, in all circumstances, a return to work,” they said.
“However, this guarantee only applies where the person remains employed on the final day of their unpaid parental leave.”
For employers and their advisers, the challenge is therefore to distinguish decisions that are commercially necessary from those improperly influenced by pregnancy or caring responsibilities – and to ensure the evidence supports that assessment.
Beyond redundancy
The AHRC’s proposed changes extend beyond dismissals.
The report identifies a gap in the Sex Discrimination Act, which prohibits direct discrimination on the basis of family responsibilities but does not provide equivalent express protection against indirect discrimination on that ground.
Cody pointed to working hours as an example of how apparently neutral requirements can disadvantage employees with caring responsibilities.
“What they will say is, you need to be able to start work at 8am and work until 5pm,” she said, explaining that rigid hours can create barriers for carers even where an employer does not expressly discriminate against them.
The commission has also proposed moving towards a presumptive right to flexible working arrangements, rather than a framework in which eligible employees have a right to request them.
As Cody put it, the assumption should be that employees can work flexibly “unless there are compelling reasons that a job can’t be designed in some sort of flexible way”.
Cant and Mills said such changes could substantially increase employers’ potential exposure to litigation, given the range of arrangements employees might seek.
“While the report does not set out the details of the proposed changes, these changes would substantially increase employers’ potential exposure to litigation if implemented,” they said.
They also emphasise the importance of workplace education and clear guidance, particularly for managers responsible for decisions about leave, flexibility and restructuring.
“While legislative reform and improved enforcement mechanisms are important, greater education and awareness among business leaders, supported by clear guidance from regulators (such as the Fair Work Ombudsman and the Australian Human Rights Commission), will make a considerable difference,” they said.
For Williams, workplace attitudes are equally significant. She argued that many businesses continue to regard parental leave and flexible work as operational inconveniences, rather than ordinary features of employment.
“It seems that businesses view workers taking parental leave or seeking flexibility as an inconvenience,” she said.
Williams believes one way to address that attitude would be to make it more difficult for employers to eliminate the positions of workers who are pregnant or on parental leave without first demonstrating that the decision is justified.
She argued that employers should face greater procedural hurdles before making the positions of pregnant workers or employees on parental leave redundant, so that retaining those workers becomes a more attractive option.
From protection to prevention
The AHRC report also calls for greater investment in legal assistance, more accessible information about workplace rights and improvements to how complaints are handled.
Cody said employers’ existing positive duty to prevent and eliminate relevant forms of discrimination provides an important foundation for more proactive action.
“I think we can be a little bit more active in educating employers around that,” she said.
That being said, she believes lasting change will also require workplaces to move beyond assumptions that employees with caring responsibilities are less committed or less available.
“I think it’s culture change,” Cody said, pointing to the need to encourage men and non-birthing parents to take parental leave and share caring responsibilities.
For Cant and Mills, prevention begins with decision-makers who understand their obligations and can demonstrate that employment decisions are supported by legitimate reasons and appropriate processes.
“Ultimately, acts of pregnancy and parental discrimination are taken not by businesses, but by individuals within a business,” they said.
“To manage these risks, employers must ensure that senior leaders, particularly those involved in decision making, are clear on what their legal obligations are and have mechanisms in place to stay up to date as those obligations evolve.”
For Williams, meaningful reform must also address the imbalance between workers attempting to challenge a decision and employers who control much of the relevant information.
She argued that retaining experienced employees should not be regarded simply as a compliance obligation, but as a benefit to businesses themselves.
“There are so many benefits to businesses to retain existing staff,” she said.
These perspectives point to a common challenge: legal protections are most effective when they influence workplace decisions before an employee is forced to seek a remedy.
Australia’s existing laws provide important safeguards against pregnancy and parental discrimination. Whether the proposed reforms will strengthen those protections may ultimately depend on more than the obligations Parliament adopts. The greater test will be whether they change workplace decisions before employees are forced to seek legal remedies.